I Capture the Castle, Dodie Smith

Book Title: I Capture the Castle

Author: Dodo Smith

Date Started: June 8th  2025

Date Completed: June 18th 2025

Genres: Historical, Romance

Quality Rating: Four Stars

Enjoyment Rating: Four Star

Final Rating: Four Stars

Review:

I love the film version of I Capture the Castle, and have had the novel on my shelf for a decade and a half. There are some moments that have always stuck with me (the Midsummer rights, the writing study in the ruined castle, Cassandra and Stephen in the woods and then beside the Thames), but it was a pleasure to rediscover the whole story in its own right.

A British classic, it is beautiful and melancholic and fanciful and quaint. I certainly haven't read many contemporary 1930s/40s stories that aren't WWII focused. I wasn't aware of the history of the book before reading (Dodie Smith and her husband, a conscientious objector, left Britain during the war for California) but it makes sense in its nostalgic nature, reflecting on the everyday lives of people making connections with others unlike themselves, and the messes we make even with the best of intentions. It is a timeless representation of girlhood, both in its moments of exact shared experience as well as the wild imaginings of adventure.

More so than the film, the book is such a collection of character portraits. Despite being told in first person by Cassandra, who spends varying amounts of times with different people, it struck me how full each character was in their own rite, and the ways that that impacted Cassandra's life. She's not a passive protagonist, but is navigating the decisions of those around her as much as her own - and it's so interesting to learn more and more about these people from their actions that we might not have expected.

I'm so used to first person narrators (especially young women) being intentionally headstrong or sickly sweet or just seeming to care so much about what the reader thinks of them - notably, the reader over the characters they're existing beside. Cassandra is so inexcusably herself and strikingly kind and intelligent and growing as she learns that's not always enough.